Going forward, this means that retailers will have to work harder to engage customers in an exponentially more competitive market. This has placed even greater importance on understanding your audience.
Whilst some will be drawn in by FOMO-inducing tactics like VIP early-access sales and passcode-locked sites, which help maintain engagement throughout the period, others will be fatigued by longer Black Friday promotions, and respond better to shorter campaigns. Identifying what resonates best with your audience through a strong foundation of customer data will be key to driving YoY success.
AI-driven personalization was the differentiator
With Black Friday campaigns stretching weeks, not days, sky-high inbox competition, and buyers that are savvier than ever, AI-driven personalization and segmentation emerged this year as a crucial point of differentiation for high-performing retail businesses.
Our research shows that increasing send volume is no longer enough to stand out in the crowded inboxes of today’s consumer – particularly in the most competitive quarter of the year. To cut through the noise, the winners of Black Friday 2024 embraced next-generation personalization strategies powered by AI, leveraging data and machine learning to deliver messaging that truly resonated.
For example, this year we saw our clients using predictive affinity algorithms to fine-tune product recommendations, imagery, and content based on browsing and purchase behavior, or implementing predictive frequency modelling to send a message when a customer is most likely to convert.
In a hyper-competitive landscape where discount fatigue has made consumers increasingly harder to convert, these tactics have evolved beyond nice-to-haves into essentials, and will remain a top priority for brands looking to have an even better 2025.
Savvy retailers prioritized multichannel campaigns
Email may be a Black Friday mainstay, but some of the strongest campaigns we saw across our customer base this year were multichannel ones.
Email remained a powerhouse during Black Friday 2024, driving an impressive 16.3% of total revenue over Cyber Week according to our data. This was a slight decrease on last year’s figure of 18.7%. Engagement metrics were largely the same this year and last, with human open rate rising marginally from 5.9% to 6.1%, and CTR down slightly from 1.1% to 1%.
However, given how intense the competition for customer attention is at peak, the savviest retailers focused on diversifying beyond email and meeting their audience where they are - from SMS to push notifications to paid social and beyond.
2024 was a particularly strong year for SMS, driven in part by the huge popularity of mobile shopping, with mobile devices accounting for 55% of online sales.
Many of our clients made smart use of the channel, with its higher click and conversion rates, for driving a quick response; from dropping daily deals (like DUSK.COM), to announcing limited time offers (like Crew Clothing Company).
But ultimately, SMS is at its most powerful when integrated as part of a joined-up cross-channel approach, and based on rich customer data. When you make that a priority, you can truly personalize and tailor every message.
Top strategies balanced acquisition and retention
Though customer acquisition is undoubtedly a priority for retailers at Black Friday, 2024 highlighted the importance of balancing it with retention to build a successful peak season strategy.
This year, our data shows that 56.4% of orders made over Cyber Week were repeat purchases, highlighting a clear trend: consumers are spending with brands they already know and trust, meaning retailers that had invested in cultivating direct relationships with their customers saw significant gains.
This places ever greater importance on a strong foundation of customer data, allowing retailers to both identify and nurture their loyal customers with compelling, personalized messages.
Interestingly, however, our data found that the average order value (AOV) of a new customer is slightly higher (6.5%) than that of a returning one, bucking the usual trend of returning customers spending more.
Want best practice strategies from our experts on how to turn your holiday shoppers into long-term brand loyalists? Check out our Post Black-Friday Checklist for 2024.
Learnings for 2025
Black Friday 2024 saw retailers that balanced early customer activation with strong retention efforts, leveraged AI-driven personalization, and nurtured long-term relationships emerged as clear winners. As we look ahead to 2025, the key takeaway is clear: success lies in creating value-driven, personalized experiences that resonate beyond the holiday rush.
–
Ometria is a Customer Data and Experience Platform exclusively for retailers, which means that, unlike other CDP/CDMP/ESP tech providers we are uniquely positioned to understand the retail challenges, use cases, and opportunities of retail events like BFCM. If you want your 2025 Black Friday to be even bigger and better, why not speak to one of our team to understand how the retail experience and expertise of Ometria’s technology and team can help you to hit your goals. Get in touch here.